On How Many Things is Pakistan Dependent on India?

---

The relationship between India and Pakistan has long been defined by competition, conflict, and, at times, cooperation. While the two nations share a complex and tumultuous history, there are areas where Pakistan remains materially dependent on India. Despite political tensions and security challenges, certain aspects of Pakistan’s economy, infrastructure, and resources are intricately tied to its neighbor. In this article, we will explore the various domains in which Pakistan depends on India, focusing on water, trade, energy, healthcare, and agricultural supplies.

1. Water Resources and the Indus River System

One of the most significant areas of dependence for Pakistan on India is water resources. The Indus River system, which is vital to Pakistan’s agriculture, drinking water, and overall water supply, originates in India. The 1960 Indus Waters Treaty, which divides the water from the Indus River system between India and Pakistan, gives Pakistan control of the three western rivers—Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab—while India has control over the eastern rivers: Ravi, Beas, and Sutlej.

However, Pakistan’s dependence on India remains evident in the flow of water from these rivers. Any alterations in the management of water resources by India could significantly impact Pakistan, particularly in the context of agricultural production. Issues such as the construction of dams, changes in water storage, or diversion projects in India could drastically affect Pakistan’s water supply, leading to tensions. The ongoing issue of water sharing remains a cornerstone of Pakistan’s dependence on India, particularly as Pakistan’s agriculture relies heavily on the irrigation of these rivers.

2. Trade and Economic Interdependence

Despite the often tense political relations, trade between India and Pakistan has been an important economic factor. Historically, India has been a vital trading partner for Pakistan, supplying goods like machinery, chemicals, and industrial products. Though direct trade between the two countries has been limited due to security concerns and political restrictions, informal trade and smuggling still exist, especially in regions near the border.

Furthermore, Pakistan has at times depended on Indian exports for essential goods, including food items such as vegetables, fruits, and grains. In the past, Pakistan has also relied on India for machinery and equipment needed for industrial production, given India’s larger and more developed manufacturing sector. Trade through formal channels has been restricted since the suspension of cross-border trade in 2019, but the interdependence between the economies, particularly in terms of the exchange of essential commodities, has been evident.

Although political dynamics often hamper the potential for increased trade, India’s strong manufacturing base and its ability to produce goods at competitive prices make it an important trade partner for Pakistan. Should diplomatic relations improve, greater economic cooperation could provide both nations with significant benefits.

3. Energy Imports from India

Pakistan faces an energy crisis, with frequent power shortages and a growing demand for electricity. In the past, Pakistan has looked to India as a potential supplier of electricity. While the energy infrastructure of the two countries remains divided, there have been efforts to connect their energy grids. India has a larger and more diversified energy infrastructure, including renewable energy sources like solar and wind power, which Pakistan could benefit from.

For regions near the border, electricity imports from India could help alleviate power shortages. Although political challenges often hinder such cooperation, the need for energy, particularly in areas like Punjab, where the demand is high, may lead Pakistan to explore further options for energy trade with India. The potential for importing electricity from India could ease some of the pressure on Pakistan’s own power sector, which has struggled with underdevelopment and inefficiency.

Additionally, energy cooperation could include the import of natural gas, which India imports from various sources, including Central Asia and the Middle East. While energy imports from India are not a primary source, this area of dependence highlights the growing need for cooperation on energy security between the two nations.

4. Medical Treatment and Healthcare

Pakistan is also dependent on India for medical treatment and healthcare. India’s healthcare system, particularly in private hospitals and specialized medical centers, is considered to be one of the best in the region. Many Pakistanis, especially those living near the border, seek medical treatment in India due to the high quality of care available at a relatively lower cost compared to Western countries.

Specialized treatments in fields like cardiology, oncology, and orthopedics are often sought by Pakistani patients in India. India’s reputation as a medical tourism hub draws patients from around the world, including from Pakistan, where the healthcare infrastructure can be lacking in certain areas. Complex surgeries, medical procedures, and treatments for conditions like cancer or heart disease are often more accessible in India, which remains an important destination for Pakistani patients seeking high-quality healthcare.

This reliance on Indian medical facilities also extends to the availability of advanced medical technology, pharmaceuticals, and expertise. While Pakistan has made strides in improving its healthcare sector, India’s medical capabilities continue to play a significant role in meeting the healthcare needs of many Pakistanis.

5. Agricultural Supplies and Fertilizer

Agriculture is a vital sector of Pakistan’s economy, and the country is highly dependent on agricultural inputs, some of which are imported from India. Fertilizers, agricultural chemicals, and high-quality seeds are critical to sustaining Pakistan’s agricultural production, especially for crops like wheat, cotton, and rice. India, being one of the largest producers of agricultural goods, including fertilizers and seeds, has been an important supplier for Pakistan.

Due to the nature of agriculture in Pakistan, where much of the farming is done through irrigation, maintaining soil quality and crop health is vital. Fertilizers and other agricultural inputs from India help ensure that Pakistan’s agricultural sector remains productive. Disruptions in the supply of these goods due to political tensions or trade restrictions can severely affect Pakistan’s farming industry, which relies on consistent access to such supplies.

Furthermore, India’s expertise in crop management and farming techniques has contributed to agricultural innovation in Pakistan, even if through informal channels. Given the importance of agriculture to Pakistan’s economy and food security, its dependence on Indian agricultural supplies remains a notable factor in the bilateral relationship.

Conclusion

Pakistan’s dependence on India in several critical areas is evident, despite the political and security tensions that exist between the two nations. Whether it is the water resources from the Indus River system, the trade of essential goods, energy imports, medical treatment, or agricultural supplies, Pakistan has significant material dependencies on its neighbor. These interdependencies underline the importance of cooperation, despite the challenges posed by political differences.

While India enjoys a stronger economic position and has fewer material dependencies on Pakistan, the interconnectedness of the two countries in these specific domains cannot be ignored. The complexities of these dependencies highlight the potential for mutual benefit, should diplomatic relations improve. Ultimately, addressing these areas of interdependence could lead to greater regional cooperation, benefiting both countries in the long term.